SHI Yangzi,HUANG Tingting,LUO Jianyong,et al.Evaluation on the Accuracy of Structure From Motion(SfM)Photogrammetry on Gully Surveying[J].Research of Soil and Water Conservation,2020,27(01):39-46.
SfM摄影测量法测定切沟的精度评价
- Title:
- Evaluation on the Accuracy of Structure From Motion(SfM)Photogrammetry on Gully Surveying
- 文章编号:
- 1005-3409(2020)01-0039-08
- Keywords:
- structure from motion(SfM)photogrammetry; gully survey; real-time kinematic(RTK)GPS; ground control point; digital elevation model(DEM)
- 分类号:
- S157.1
- 文献标志码:
- A
- 摘要:
- 选取河北省滦平县两间房村的一条典型切沟,以实时动态差分(Real-time Kinematic,RTK)GPS的测量结果为基准,评估了断面测量法与SfM方法对该切沟的测量精度,并在此基础上探讨不同地面控制点(Ground Control Point,GCP)布设方案对SfM测量精度的影响。结果表明:SfM测量法可作为一种高精度的方法运用于切沟测量,与RTK GPS相比,断面测量法的体积测量误差高达37.28%; 而SfM方法的误差仅为2.40%,且相对RTK GPS所测切沟DEM的差值主要集中于-0.2～0.2 m。此外,轻便、小巧的激光测距仪可有效替代RTK GPS用于GCP坐标的测量,在此基础上得到的切沟体积误差仅为0.23%。将切沟沟缘与沟底共18个GCP抽稀至4～16个,并利用SfM方法重建该切沟的三维形态。各方案所得切沟DEM相比未抽稀结果的差值主要集中于-0.05～0.05 m,且体积差值百分比均低于5%。研究结果证实,SfM摄影测量法在切沟测量中具有较高的精度,可应用于野外切沟的快速、精确测量,对于切沟定量监测与切沟侵蚀规律研究具有重要的实践意义。
- Abstract:
- A typical gully was selected and measured using the tape method and structure from motion(SfM)photogrammetry in the village of Liangjianfang, Luanping County, Hebei Province. The accuracies of both gully surveying methods were evaluated via comparing the results with those obtained by the real-time kinematic(RTK)GPS. In addition, different spatial distribution schemes of ground control points(GCPs)used in the SfM photogrammetry were designed and their impact on the gully measurement accuracy was assessed. The results show that SfM photogrammetry can serve as a highly accurate technique for gully surveying. Compared to RTK GPS, the tape method misestimates the gully volume by 37.28%, whereas the SfM photogrammetry overestimates the volume by only 2.40%, when the DEM obtained by RTK GPS is subtracted from the one by SfM photogrammetry, the resulting elevation difference falls between -0.2 m and 0.2 m for more than 70% of the pixels; moreover, the laser range finder(LRF)was demonstrated as an effective alternative for the determination of GCP coordinates; for each pair of GCPs, LRF generates statistically similar spatial distance and elevation difference with the classical RTK GPS; furthermore, the gully volume derived by SfM photogrammetry based on such GCP measurement is only misestimated by 0.23% compared to the volume obtained by RTK GPS. Reducing the number of GCPs on the gully edge and bottom from 18 to a range between 4 and 16, little difference is detected in the corresponding DEMs reconstructed by the SfM photogrammetry. Compared to the DEM grounded on all the 18 GCPs, the elevation difference is within the range between -0.05 and 0.05 m for most pixels, disregarding the number and locations of the GCPs considered. The estimation errors for gully volume, accordingly, are all smaller than 5%. These findings demonstrate that SfM photogrammetry has high precision in terms of gully measurement, and is applicable for rapid and accurate gully survey in the field, which has great practical implications for gully monitoring and gully erosion research.
参考文献/References:
[1] 朱显谟.黄土区土壤侵蚀的分类[J].土壤学报,1956,4(2):99-115.
[2] 刘宝元,杨扬,陆绍娟.几个常用土壤侵蚀术语辨析及其生产实践意义[J].中国水土保持科学,2018,16(1):9-16.
[3] 伍永秋,刘宝元.切沟、切沟侵蚀与预报[J].应用基础与工程科学学报,2000,8(2):134-142.
[4] Poesen J, Nachtergaele J, Verstraeten G, et al. Gully erosion and environmental change:importance and research needs [J]. Catena, 2003,50(2/4):91-133.
[5] 尹佳宜,伍永秋,汪言在.采用不同方法测量切沟的误差分析[J].水土保持研究,2008,15(1):12-16.
[6] Frankl A, Poesen J, Deckers J, et al. Gully head retreat rates in the semi-arid highlands of Northern Ethiopia [J]. Geomorphology, 2012,174:185-195.
[7] Ezekwe I C, Totti U A E, Wekpe V O. Gully morphometry and morphology in the Iyi-Ukwu basin, south-east, Nigeria [J]. Scientia Africana, 2014,13(2):251-265.
[8] Loughran R J. The measurement of soil erosion [J]. Progress in Physical Geography, 1989,13(2):216-233.
[9] Castillo C, Pérez R, James M R, et al. Comparing the accuracy of several field methods for measuring gully erosion [J]. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 2012,76(4):1319-1332.
[10] Kaiser A, Neugirg F, Rock G, et al. Small-scale surface reconstruction and volume calculation of soil erosion in complex Moroccan gully morphology using structure from motion [J]. Remote Sensing, 2014,6(8):7050-7080.
[11] Nouwakpo S K, Weltz M A, McGwire K. Assessing the performance of structure-from-motion photogrammetry and terrestrial LiDAR for reconstructing soil surface microtopography of naturally vegetated plots [J]. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 2016,41(3):308-322.
[12] 游智敏,伍永秋,刘宝元.利用GPS进行切沟侵蚀监测研究[J].水土保持学报,2004,18(5):91-94.
[13] 胡刚,伍永秋,刘宝元,等. GPS和GIS进行短期沟蚀研究初探:以东北漫川漫岗黑土区为例[J].水土保持学报,2004,18(4):16-19,41.
[14] Chang H, Ge L, Rizos C, et al. Validation of DEMs derived from radar interferometry, airborne laser scanning and photogrammetry by using GPS-RTK [C]∥IGARSS 2004.2004 IEEE International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium. IEEE,2004,5:2815-2818.
[15] 郑粉莉,徐锡蒙,覃超.沟蚀过程研究进展[J].农业机械学报,2016,47(8):48-59,116.
[16] Seginer I. Gully development and sediment yield [J]. Journal of Hydrology, 1966(4):236-253.
[17] Lowe D G. Object recognition from local scale-invariant features [C]∥The Proceedings of the Seventh Ieee International Conference on Computer Vision(Iccv),1999,99(2):1150-1157.
[18] Ullman S. The interpretation of structure from motion [J]. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences, 1979,203(1153):405-426.
[19] Carrivick J L, Smith M W, Quincey D J. Structure from Motion in the Geosciences [M]. UK, West Sussex, Chichester:John Wiley & Sons, 2016.
[20] Eltner A, Kaiser A, Castillo C, et al. Image-based surface reconstruction in geomorphometry-merits, limits and developments [J]. Earth Surface Dynamics, 2016,4(2):359-389.
[21] Glendell M, McShane G, Farrow L, et al. Testing the utility of structure-from-motion photogrammetry reconstructions using small unmanned aerial vehicles and ground photography to estimate the extent of upland soil erosion [J]. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 2017,42(12):1860-1871.
[22] 李俊利,李斌兵,柳方明,等.利用照片重建技术生成坡面侵蚀沟三维模型[J].农业工程学报,2015,31(1):125-132.
[23] USDA-NRCS. National soil survey handbook, title 430-Ⅵ[EB/OL]. https:∥www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/soils/ref/?cid=nrcs142 p2_054242,2019-3-11.
[24] Linder W. Digital Photogrammetry:A Practical Course, third edition [M]. Germany, Berlin:Springer, 2006:15-16.
[25] Agisoft. Agisoft metashape user manual, standard edition, Version 1.5[EB/OL]. https:∥www. agisoft. com/pdf/metashape_1_5_en. Pdf, 2019-2-28.
[26] Fischler M A, Bolles R C. Random sample consensus:a paradigm for model fitting with applications to image analysis and automated cartography [J]. Communications of the Acm, 1981,24(6):381-395.
[27] Furukawa Y, Ponce J. Accurate camera calibration from multi-view stereo and bundle adjustment [J]. International Journal of Computer Vision, 2009,84(3):257-268.
[28] Wenzel K, Rothermel M, Fritsch D, et al. Image acquisition and model selection for multi-view stereo [R]. Isprs-International Archives of the Photogrammetry, 2013.
[29] James M R, Robson S. Straightforward reconstruction of 3D surfaces and topography with a camera:Accuracy and geoscience application [J]. Journal of Geophysical Research, 2012,117, F03017.
[30] Harwin S, Lucieer A. Assessing the accuracy of georeferenced point clouds produced via multi-view stereopsis from unmanned aerial vehicle(UAV)imagery [J]. Remote Sensing, 2012,4(6):1573-1599.
备注/Memo
收稿日期:2019-03-29 修回日期:2019-04-19
资助项目:国家自然科学基金(41601277,41571130082);地表过程与资源生态国家重点实验室资助项目(2017-ZY-09)
第一作者:史扬子(1994—),女,河南焦作人,硕士研究生,主要从事土壤侵蚀与水土保持研究。E-mail:454407449@qq.com
通信作者:杨扬(1987—),女,福建将乐人,博士,讲师,主要从事土壤侵蚀与非点源污染研究。E-mail:yang.yang@bnu.edu.cn